The Advantage – A Book Review
“The single greatest advantage any company can achieve is organizational health. Yet it is ignored by most leaders even though it is simple, free, and available to anyone who wants it.”
~ Patrick Lencioni, The Advantage
I don’t usually indulge in book reviews as blog posts (there is an extensive annotated bibliography on my website), but the new book from Patrick Lencioni has prompted me to make an exception.
Not that I think it’s a great, must-read book. Far from it. But because it’s topic – organisational health – is sufficiently close to my core focus (organisational therapy), I’ve decided it’s worth mentioning by way of this review.
“After two decades of working with CEOs and their teams of senior executives, I’ve become absolutely convinced that the seminal difference between successful companies and mediocre or unsuccessful ones has little, if anything, to do with what they know or how smart they are; it has everything to do with how healthy they are.”
~ Patrick Lencioni, The Advantage
For those unfamiliar with Patrick Lencioni and his works, he has written a number of great (IMO) books including:
- The Four Obsessions of an Extraordinary Executive ★★★★★
- The Five Dysfunctions of a Team ★★★★★
- The Five Temptations of A CEO ★★★☆☆
- Getting Naked ★★★☆☆
- The Three SIgns of A Miserable Job ★★★☆☆
- Death By Meeting ★★★★★
- Silos, Politics and Turf Wars ★★★★☆
Each of these, in their own way, has been great reading; informative, thought-provoking and grounded in Lencioni’s 20+ years of consulting practice. Each has been a notable influence in my own practice.
Simply put, I found this book a disappointment. I guess this is because it’s mainly a rehash of much of his other work. I had been hoping, from the free sample, to find a book centred on the issues of organisational health. But apart from the first chapter, there’s nothing much here about organisational health per se at all. It’s as if the author has suddenly found a smart label to stick on his collective works, and tied a whole bunch of stuff together under one umbrella. Kudos for the marketing chops, at least.
His continual emphasis on the role of leaders and leadership also grates with me. For the majority of organisations – i.e. those of the Analytic mindset – I’d agree that leaders (senior execs in particular) set the tone and model the behaviours that the rest of the organisation tends to follow. But doing the wrong thing righter is, I posit, not anywhere near as useful as doing the right thing – for which I offer fellowship as a prime candidate. Ironically, then, it seems to me that an organisation that emphasises the hegemony of leaders (and the relative diminution of the role of others) is likely less healthy than it might be.
These things being said, you should read this book if you haven’t read much or any of his other works before. The Advantage offers a convenient entry point into his collective works, with sufficient references into his other books that following up on details and specifics should be simple.
The Advantage is also a departure from the author’s more usual business novel (a.k.a. ‘Fable’) format. So if you shy away from business novels, then this more prosaic, text-book approach might appeal to you. ★★☆☆☆
P.S. For the Rightshifters amongst you, I suggest that the author’s enthusiasm for organisational heath, and the benefits he attributes to it, correspond fairly closely to an organisation’s relative position on the horizontal (rightshifting) axis (i.e. the healthier an organisation, the more effective it is). More specifically, I’d say that organisational health corresponds more or less to the green (fun) line on this ‘Perspective on Rightshifting’ chart.